Welcome to ArmyAdvice Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

ArmySteve

Steve Smith's Army Blog

General Batiste Funny Story

Retired General Batiste has been in the news a bit lately for his criticism of Rumsfeld, but seeing his photo lately reminds me of a rather humorous anecdote that occurred during my deployment in 2004 under the 1st ID.  You can read the story as I originally wrote it here:

http://armyadvice.org/blogs/armysteve/archive/2004/10/03/9259.aspx

That was as much contact as I had with General Batiste, but my experience (and I'm out now, so I can be honest) was that he was a good commander, so I have a lot of respect for what he (and other veteran generals) has to say.

 

Sponsor
Published Monday, April 24, 2006 4:24 PM by ssmith

Comment Notification

If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

 

S Desch said:

I don’t doubt one bit that these retired Generals were good leaders during their time. But if they felt this way when they were in why didn’t they say something then, if it meant so much to them. Seems somewhat spineless to speak out when you have nothing to loose.  
May 5, 2006 4:34 PM
 

Pablo said:

S Desch, I'm still in the military and am also an officer.  One thing is certain about speaking your mind, you do it and if your superior decides against it, that's that.  

The one an only rule is: 'lawful order.'  If the order is legal then you follow it.  It's not that officers are spineless, is that they really believe that what they are doing is the right thing and it's not unlawful.  In the miliary structure, speaking out against your boss is 'inconceivable!'  Something about good order and discipline.

If you don't, you resign and complain about how dumb all the things you saw where just like General Zinni and General Batiste.

Being a military officer is a lonely life.  You have to achieve missions you may not agree with and take care of troops that think you're stupid because of what you tell them to do, although it wasn't your idea.  You stay with it expecting to someday being high enough to make the decisions, then realize that you'll never be that high.  

I may sound disgruntled, but I'm not.  I think the US model is the best around.  It creates a volunteer force which I think is the strength of our armed forces.  

May 18, 2007 10:50 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 
Enter the code you see below

Submit

About ssmith

Enlisted in 1995. Basic at Ft Sill. AIT at Ft Jackson (75F). Served in Ohio National Guard. Went through ROTC program at Ohio State University and received 2LT commission in 1997, Engineer branch. Spent about 4 years in 16th Engineer Brigade in Ohio National Guard, then moved far from nearest unit and went into Inactive National Guard, and eventually Individual Ready Reserve. Called up from IRR in 2004 for duty in Iraq (Engineer Platoon Leader with 1st ID). Made it home in 2005. Resigned commission as a CPT in December 2005.